Bow Down to your Bureaucrat God

“If cattle and horses…were able to draw with their feet and produce the works which men do, horses would draw the forms of gods like horses, and cattle like cattle, and they would make the gods’ bodies the same shape as their own.”

— Xenophanes (ancient Greek philosopher)

Some readers might have heard of Yuval Noah Harari. I’ve never read any of his books, but he has popped up in my internet travels over the years, usually in connection with Klaus Schwab, the erstwhile Bond-villanesque leader of the WEF. Harari strikes me as a very dumb person who does a good job of pretending to be smart. He can get away with it, though, since his job involves nothing more than speculating about the future in abstract terms that can’t be proven wrong.

People like Harari do have a certain value. Their pronouncements are not to be taken literally but symbolically as depictions of the underlying values of the social class to which they belong. Harari is the high priest of the bureaucrat class of modern society. His prophetic visions reveal much about the values of that class.

That is nowhere clearer than in a video of his that I stumbled across this week. Harari posted it on his social media accounts. It only goes for a minute and a half. You can watch it here.

The presentation revolves around the incredibly banal point that cows can’t understand the stock market. But buried beneath that statement of the obvious is the key that unlocks the deeper meaning of his thought experiment. The key lies in a concept that should be universally known (and would be if our education system were worth a damn). The concept is the great chain of being.

Like all Western thought, the great chain of being began with Plato and was then significantly expanded upon by Aristotle. Each level in the chain builds on the one that came before. The great mystery is how the chain came into being and how it actually sustains itself. Fortunately, we don’t need to go into that here. We just need to know the basic overview.

The first level in the chain is inanimate matter. The second is living beings. Living beings are made of matter but have additional properties such as growth and metabolism. That is why we say that living beings are “higher” in the chain. They have more properties than the lower level.

Animals form the third category. They are made of matter, have growth and metabolism, but also have properties that plants do not have, such as consciousness, movement, and goal-directed action. The fourth category is us. Humans have an animal nature, but we have additional properties which distinguish us from the animals such as self-consciousness and the ability to direct our thinking.

When Harari says that cows cannot understand the stock market, he is referring to the qualitative difference that exists between the animal and human categories of being. Since cows are incapable of symbolic thinking, they can never understand markets. It is forever invisible to them. By contrast, we humans can understand something of what it is like to be a cow because we share their animal nature.

The question that Plato and Aristotle pondered was whether there was a level of being above the human. They both answered yes for different reasons. For the sake of simplicity, lets just call that level of being “god”. God has properties that humans do not. God also includes humanity and all the lower levels of beings.

We have said that cows lack symbolic thinking and can therefore never understand something like the stock market. The level of being above is forever invisible to them. The same is not true for humans in our relationship to God. God is a level of being above us, but we can know something about it.

Plato and Aristotle believed that we could access the divine level of being through the practice of philosophy. Other religious thinkers have said we can access it in other ways. In any case, it is not forever closed to us. Thus, we do not stand in relation to the level of the divine in the way that a cow stands in relation to the stock market.

In the modern world, we have got rid of this way of thinking for the most part and replaced it with an inversion of the levels of being whereby the chain of being was constructed over time, beginning with inanimate matter and leading up to humanity via evolution. Harari is an atheist who believes in science, and so he falls into this modern worldview. This doesn’t matter much for our purposes, however. The levels of being stay the same; we just get rid of the level above the human.

Now that we know the intellectual background, we can return to Hariri’s cute little video about cows and humans. In the modern atheist viewpoint, humans are the most evolved creatures, the only ones capable of understanding such wonders as the stock market. But, wait! Harari tells us that a new entity has just arrived on the scene, and it stands in the same relation to us as we do to cows. This entity is, of course, none other than “AI”.

AI has taken many imaginative forms over the years. Harari explicitly dismisses the idea of terminator-style robots. The AI that he thinks is going to take over the world is some kind of super bureaucrat. As he puts it, AI’s are “bureaucratic natives”. We humans are still tied to the animal world, and this is holding us back, you see. AIs have no such limitations. They were born in the bureaucratic womb, children of bureaucrat Zion, and they shall lead us to the promised land where all bank account details may be retrieved in a nanosecond and you never have to sit on the phone getting transferred from one department to another. The bureaucrat-AI god will take care of it all.

Has there ever been a more pitiful vision of the divine realm? I doubt it. What’s more, there are logical holes you could drive a truck through in Harari’s argument. But that is not important. What is important is the vision itself and underlying values it reveals. It is not by accident that Harari gets to speak at the WEF and similar institutions since they are populated by people who are children of the bureaucrat Zion. They really do believe this stuff.

For that reason, the final move that Harari makes in his speech is highly illuminating. Remember, both Plato and Aristotle believed that humans could reach up to the divine realm. Plato’s famous cave allegory is about that. Our vision is dull, but we can strive to see.

That is not the case with Harari’s new bureaucrat-AI god. We meagre humans with our tiny little brains won’t be able to perceive its genius. It will create brand-new financial markets that are beyond our understanding. We will stand in relation to it as the cow stands in relation to the stock market: eternally blind. Thus, we are denied what Plato, Aristotle, and the subsequent Christian thinkers who synthesised their ideas asserted. We are denied access to the level of being above ourselves.

Of course, this is preposterous. Bureaucracies and financial markets are the creations of humans. Why would we suddenly be unable to understand them? But, again, these ideas are not to be taken seriously at a logical level. Rather, they are fever dreams of the bureaucrat class of society. How does that bureaucrat class see us? Simple. They see us as cows. You don’t try to explain the stock market to a cow; you just feed it into the machine. Harari will be the high priest mediating between the bureaucrat-AI god and the rest of us. Our job is to do as we are told like good little herd animals.

This way of thinking demotes humanity down one rung in the chain of being. Harari assumes that we will somehow lose our ability to think, to strive, to improve. His vision does not just imply the emergence of an AI-god, but the devolution of the human. We humans will somehow revert back a level on the chain of being and literally become cows. To say it again, though, that is simply what our bureaucrat overlords want for us. They want us to be cows.

But I think this bureaucrat fever dream is even more revealing than that. It is actually a form of self-confession. It is the bureaucrats who are the cows. Bureaucracies turn people into herd animals. Bureaucracies require us to be docile, obedient and to follow the rules. That is true of us as “customers”, but even more true for the people who work in bureaucracies. To work in a bureaucracy is to relinquish the qualities that make you human. You give up self-directed thinking and become nothing more than a cog in the machine.

Thus, Harari’s future is already here. The children of bureaucrat Zion are the cows, the bureaucracy is their God, AI is their prophet. All hail the great customer service representative in the sky!

4 thoughts on “Bow Down to your Bureaucrat God”

  1. Willem – hah! I haven’t read Wells in so long that I had to look that up. I guess the laptop classes are one step closer to that vision, although the Morlocks have been outsourced.

  2. Hi Simon, I think that humans have always liked to see other humans as lesser beings (cows!). That is the underlying basis of rascism, bigotry, misogyny, religious wars, ethnic cleaning etc. Once a group of people are viewed as ‘other’ they can be treated as sub human. AI is a human construct, like the share market, etc etc et al. Chickens have pecking orders that we don’t understand, as I am sure cows do. Humans are just egotistic enough to believe that our constructs are the best and ignore the rest. That’s why shark attacks are so widely reported on – imagine a lesser species treating us like food! Mon dieu! Sandra

  3. Sandra – good point. Ideologies that paint one group as the bad guys have a very nasty habit of providing cover for atrocities.

    What’s interesting about Hariri though is that you get the impression that he likes the idea of an AI-god. It’s a not uncommon thing that some so-called atheists do. Having rejected one version of the divine, they sneak another in through the back door.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *